PUBLIC ARCHIVE INDEX – CONSOLIDATED LEGAL DOCUMENTS & ANNEXURES (1997–2026)
English • 中文（简体） • Bahasa Melayu
ENGLISH: Consolidated legal documents, timelines, and annexures relating to property rights, registration errors, insurance disputes, and professional negligence.
中文（简体）: 涵盖产权、登记错误、保险争议及专业疏忽的合并法律文件、时间线与附录。
BAHASA MELAYU: Dokumen undang‑undang, garis masa dan lampiran berkaitan hak milik, kesilapan pendaftaran, pertikaian insurans dan kecuaian profesional.
ENGLISH PUBLIC ARCHIVE INDEX – CONSOLIDATED LEGAL DOCUMENTS & ANNEXURES (1997–2026)
A structured repository of timelines, legal authorities, and documentary evidence relating to property rights, registration errors, insurance disputes, and professional negligence matters.
All financial quantum has been redacted from this public version for privacy and safety.
中文（简体）公开档案索引 – 合并法律文件与附录（1997–2026）
本索引系统性整理了时间线、法律依据，以及与产权、登记错误、保险争议和专业疏忽相关的所有证据文件。
所有金额已从公开版本中删节以确保安全。
BAHASA MELAYU – INDEKS ARKIB AWAM (1997–2026)
Indeks ini menghimpunkan garis masa, asas undang‑undang dan bukti dokumentari berkaitan hak milik, kesilapan pendaftaran, pertikaian insurans dan kecuaian profesional.
Semua jumlah kewangan telah dipadamkan daripada versi awam.
INTRODUCTION (EN / BM / CN)
This post archives the consolidated Annex C–E submitted in support of my multi‑agency claims involving Law Mutual (WA), AAI/Vero, QBE/AFCA, and the Landgate Assurance Fund. These annexures document the full timeline of events from 1997 to 2026, the legal authorities supporting each claim, and the losses arising from the loss of S.52PLAISQE, converted fixtures, and registration errors.
All quantum has been removed from this public archive for safety.
Malay:
Catatan ini mengarkibkan Lampiran C–E yang disatukan sebagai sokongan kepada tuntutan saya terhadap Law Mutual (WA), AAI/Vero, QBE/AFCA dan Dana Jaminan Landgate. Semua jumlah kerugian telah dipadamkan demi keselamatan。
Chinese:
本篇文章公开存档我向 Law Mutual (WA)、AAI/Vero、QBE/AFCA 及 Landgate Assurance Fund 提交的合并附录 C–E。所有损失金额已从公开版本中删节以确保安全。
ANNEX C – TIMELINE OF EVENTS (1997–2026)
1. Origin of Rights (1997–1998)
8 Dec 1997 – City of Swan advertises Unit 1/383 as the single dedicated lunch bar.
17 Dec 1997 – WAPC approves lunch bar use (File P190639).
9 Mar 1998 – Strata Plan 34659 lodged.
28 Apr 1998 – WAPC issues Form 26.
4 Aug 1998 – First Transfer: Filippous registered with S.52PLAISQE intact.
2. Second Transfer & Negligence (1999–2000)
17 Nov 1999 – 23 Feb 2000 – V. Ozich & Co engaged.
23 Feb 2000 – Second Transfer completed without S.52PLAISQE → latent defect created.
3. Tenancy, Fixtures & Insurable Interest (2005–2016)
4 Apr 2005 – Business Sale Agreement executed.
3 Oct 2010 – Lease requiring return of fixtures.
14 Feb 2016 – Tenants remove fixtures and relocate S.52PLAISQE to Unit 10/383.
4. Insurance Disputes (2016–2020)
25 Jul 2016 – FOS (Ainscow) limits compensation to iron gates.
2017–2018 – PPSR confirms plant & equipment loss.
2018–2020 – Communications with QBE, CHU, Suncorp, Vero.
5. Court Proceedings (2017–2019)
CIV 134/2017 → CIV 2904/2017 → CIV 2074/2018
30 Aug 2018 – Vaughan J judgment.
7 Aug 2019 – WASCA dismisses appeal.
4 Sep 2019 – High Court application P43/2019 filed.
6. Law Mutual Investigation (2019–2020)
5 Dec 2019 – 15 Jan 2020 – Popperwell appointed.
Feb–Apr 2020 – Memoranda exchanged.
14 May 2020 – Claimant’s reply summarises negligence.
7. Landgate & FOI Searches (2020)
1 May 2020 – FOI returns nil.
5–11 May 2020 – Notice of Potential Claim lodged.
21 May 2020 – City of Swan confirms no annotations.
8. AFCA Complaint (2020)
29 Apr 2020 – AFCA deadline expires.
1 Jun 2020 – AFCA requests bundle.
2 Jun 2020 – Annex A submitted.
9. Consolidated Notice (2026)
1 Feb 2026 – Consolidated Notice sent to all agencies.
ANNEX D – LEGAL AUTHORITIES & PRINCIPLES
1. Professional Negligence – Law Mutual
Authorities: Scarcella v Lettice; Winnote v Page; Registrar General v Cleaver; Christopoulos v Angelos
Principles:
– Latent defects accrue upon discovery
– Conveyancers must identify all easements and appurtenant rights
– Failure to transfer S.52PLAISQE constitutes negligence
2. Insurance Misassessment – QBE / AFCA
Authorities: Insurance Contracts Act 1984; FOS/AFCA precedents; CHU underwriting guidelines
Principles:
– Fixtures forming part of the building are insurable
– PPSR confirms plant & equipment loss
– FOS (Ainscow) erred in limiting compensation
3. Landgate Assurance Fund – Registration Error
Authorities: Transfer of Land Act 1893; Hermansen (Easements Not Mentioned); Indian Easements Act 1882
Principles:
– Landgate must preserve implied easements
– Omission of S.52PLAISQE is compensable
4. Unity of Ownership & Implied Rights
Authorities: Property Law Act (WA); common law doctrine of unity of ownership
Principles:
– S.52PLAISQE is an implied right appurtenant to Unit 1/383
ANNEX E – QUANTUM SUMMARY (PUBLIC REDACTED VERSION)
All monetary amounts have been removed for privacy and safety. Full quantum has been provided privately to the relevant authorities.
1. Loss Attributable to Law Mutual (Negligence)
– Present value of easement rights: [REDACTED]
– Loss of rental (2016–present): [REDACTED]
– Future rental loss (in perpetuity): [REDACTED]
– Outgoings on defunct unit: [REDACTED]
– Legal costs: [REDACTED]
Subtotal: [REDACTED]
2. Loss Attributable to QBE / AFCA (Insurance Misassessment)
– Plant & equipment (PPSR): [REDACTED]
– Building‑related losses: [REDACTED]
– Interest & consequential loss: [REDACTED]
Subtotal: [REDACTED]
3. Loss Attributable to Landgate (Assurance Fund)
– Diminution in value due to missing S.52PLAISQE: [REDACTED]
– Statutory compensation: [REDACTED]
Subtotal: [REDACTED]
END OF CONSOLIDATED ANNEX C–E (PUBLIC REDACTED VERSION)
English
This archive is published in the public interest to ensure transparency, accountability, and procedural fairness. All quantum has been removed from the public version for safety.
Malay
Arkib ini diterbitkan demi kepentingan awam. Semua jumlah kewangan telah dipadamkan demi keselamatan。
Chinese
本档案以公共利益为目的发布。所有金额已从公开版本
PUBLIC TRANSPARENCY & ARCHIVAL NOTICE
ENGLISH: This archive is published in the public interest to ensure transparency, accountability, and procedural fairness. All financial quantum has been removed from the public version for safety.
中文（简体）: 本档案以公共利益为目的发布，以确保透明度、问责性及程序公正。所有金额已从公开版本中删节以确保安全。
BAHASA MELAYU: Arkib ini diterbitkan demi kepentingan awam bagi memastikan ketelusan, akauntabiliti dan keadilan prosedur. Semua jumlah kewangan telah dipadamkan demi keselamatan.
© 1997–2026 Consolidated Legal Archive – Public Redacted Version
No comments:
Post a Comment